Armageddon: When failed QE and asset prices collide

6 Nov 2012

In their desperate scramble for growth, the Fed and ECB have finally revealed they are willing to print unlimited amounts of money. Yet, there is growing recognition among the investment community that quantitative easing (QE) on its own cannot and will not be enough to generate economic growth. It does, however, artificially inflate asset prices and worsen institutions’ funding levels.

“Quantitative easing creates a short-term sugar rush for risk assets.”

Stewart Richardson

Meanwhile, politicians are continually failing to do their bit to help address the mounting debt problems or find a workable solution to the eurozone crisis. When it becomes clear that QE is going to fail if it does not receive the necessary political support, asset prices will correct downwards sharply. This presents institutions with a double-whammy as asset values fall when investors can least afford it.

Easing makes life harder

The irony of QE is that it makes life significantly harder for institutional investors. With the Fed and ECB ready to undertake unlimited amounts of easing in their attempts to shore up their economies and generate growth, the picture for UK institutions also deteriorates markedly.

In a world where no country can afford to become less competitive, the pressure on the Bank of England (BoE) to follow suit will likely prove harder to resist. Consensus among experts is increasingly pointing towards further intervention in the UK.

Stewart Richardson, chief investment officer at RMG Wealth Management, says he expects to see another £50bn added to the asset purchase programme come November’s meeting, taking the total to £425bn and, according to Sandra Crowl, who sits on the investment committee at Carmignac Gestion: “The growth rate in the UK continues to be disappointing so I expect the Bank of England won’t have a problem expanding its balance sheet further.”

The problem of further easing in the UK is it has a direct, often detrimental impact on institutions’ funding status. A further extension of the asset purchase programme would, therefore, likely leave them in a more precarious position heading into next year. While QE provides support for risk assets, helping offset the increase in liabilities, that is only any good if the impact on both assets and liabilities occurs over the same timespan. That is unlikely to be the case.

Pension Corporation calculates, using the BoE’s own assumptions on the impact of QE, that every basis point yield drop across the gilt curve increases liabilities for defined benefit pension funds by around £2bn. On 4 March 2009, the day before the first round of QE, the yield on the 30-year gilt was 4.3%. By 2 October this year, the 30-year gilt yield had fallen 120 basis points to 3.1%, equivalent to a £240bn increase in liabilities (see chart). While QE is not the only factor affecting yield movements, its impact is certainly very significant and another extension of the asset purchase programme is widely expected to help push yields lower.

However, the effectiveness of QE is dying off with each new round of easing. As Mark Gull, co-head of asset and liability management at Pension Corporation, says: “When QE started in 2009, it was a broadly good thing given the concerns over inflation, gilt yields of around 4.3% at the time and the Bank of England’s focus on the longer end of the yield curve. It has subsequently become less effective and the side effects are coming more into focus. The BoE now owns 40% of the gilt market. How much more can they do without creating an even bigger distortion?”

The deterioration of funding levels has also led to the 15% hike in the Pension Protection Fund levy for 2013 with further 10% increases expected in 2014 and 2015, but the impact does not stop there. Widening deficits also limit companies’ ability to generate the growth and employment QE is designed to stimulate by diverting money that could otherwise be used to invest in companies or return to investors.

Smiths Group chief executive Philip Bowman, warned the BoE in September that the £375bn bond-buying scheme was forcing companies to plug widening holes in their pension funds rather than investing in those businesses or increasing dividends. Smiths has pumped £378m into its pension scheme over the last five years to try and tackle its growing deficit, which more than trebled in the last financial year from £199m to £620m. Bowman pointed to the asset purchase programme driving yields down as a major factor in the jump in deficit. The deficit would lower if bonds yields rose but, even if that meant the scheme became over-funded, the company would be unable to recoup the money for investment at a later date.

QE and asset prices

Funding levels are not the only factor affected by QE for institutional investors. It also has a very significant impact on the asset side of the equation, which, despite providing short-term support for prices, could mean a sharp downward correction in the coming months.

“Quantitative easing creates a short-term sugar rush for risk assets,” says RMG’s Richardson, “but little momentum is given to the economy. Structural changes are needed to build the economy. When markets realise QE is not working, the price will have to be paid as assets have been pushed above where they should be. That, in turn, ensures future returns are depressed as markets recalibrate downwards.”

Many experts believe that correction could come as early as 2013.

More Articles

Newsletter

Magazine

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign up to the portfolio institutional newsletter to receive a weekly update with our latest features, interviews, ESG content, opinion, roundtables and event invites.

Magazine Subscription

Institutional investors qualify for a free of charge subscription to portfolio institutional. Please fill in your details to request your copy.

Magazine

Magazine Subscription

Institutional investors qualify for a free of charge subscription to portfolio institutional. Please fill in your details to request your copy.

We use cookies to improve your experience on this website. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.