We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".



Twitter board

Follow us
  • @NewtonIM Sustainable Bond Investing Newton’s Scott Freedman and Victoria Barron review some of the developments in… https://t.co/6woi4Dfqjc13 hours ago
  • RT @portfolio_inst: @InvescoUKinsti whitepaper: Sustainable factor investing ''The advent of what might be called sustainable factor invest…2 days ago
  • @InvescoUKinsti whitepaper: Sustainable factor investing ''The advent of what might be called sustainable factor in… https://t.co/rPdm94o9yU2 days ago
  • Old Money: Forget millennial's, pension funds looking for growth should be targeting cash-rich retirees.… https://t.co/TfPklO4QPr2 days ago
  • RT @MSCI_Cudworth: MSCI in the News. EM governance: Breaking through. Michael Cheng discusses the influence of corporate #governance in #…2 days ago
  • Our cover story: CDC: A step into the unknown. Is CDC an unnecessary policy change when effort would be better spen… https://t.co/QGHfTkiPP27 days ago
  • Newton – Trend Setting: The Year Ahead in ESG ''We have seen notable client interest for sustainable products over… https://t.co/OoXVLJ1BMp7 days ago
  • Our Latest ESG feature: EM governance: Breaking through. ''Those calling for better governance in emerging markets… https://t.co/qk0vJpfpJL10 days ago
  • The February Issue is available online now! Our Cover Story - CDC: A Step in the wrong direction. Read more here:… https://t.co/8xwHL9Nd2z10 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: What do we expect to see in the #ESG market over the next 12 months? Read the results of the @portfolio_inst panel of…10 days ago
  • RT @PensionsSion: What are the pros and cons of building a global #equity portfolio? Find out by reading the @portfolio_inst Global Equitie…16 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Outcomes delivered by employer pension schemes now depend more than ever on levels of engagement. Companies must creat…17 days ago
  • Our latest Roundtable: Cash-Flow Driven Investing is now live! Read more here: https://t.co/zBy7Gbiud9 https://t.co/KJTIgVssmG17 days ago
  • RT @BNPPAM_COM: 2017 was one of the most active hurricane seasons on record, causing up to USD 475 billion worth of damage. What are the in…29 days ago
  • RT @PensionsTony: At the Aon London #pensions conference. About to start my workshop on how well #DC schemes are meeting the needs of #memb…29 days ago
  • Andrew Wauchope talks to Mark Dunne about charities and their pension schemes, the secret of being a good trustee a… https://t.co/xcdcxs61QL29 days ago
  • Enter the Dragon : China’s inclusion in the @MSCI_Inc Emerging Market index has caused little excitement, but, as L… https://t.co/oy0EdSI6A831 days ago
  • The @InvescoUKinsti whitepaper: Responsible investing and active ownership. Invesco’s Bonnie Saynay and Henning St… https://t.co/E3Gdh9eDSM36 days ago
  • Charlotte Moore looks at the reaction of financial markets to Brexit has already changed the shape of the relations… https://t.co/6KH9jnWTtq36 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Want to know more about the benefits of factor-based investing for your DB pension scheme? Aon’s next Investment Break…37 days ago


A special feature from our sponsor SYZ Asset Management – ‘Contrarian investing in the Italian banking crisis’

A special feature from our sponsor SYZ Asset Management – ‘Contrarian investing in the Italian banking crisis’

Pras Jeyanandhan, senior analyst, SYZ Asset Management
Tuesday 12th September 2017

The onset of the financial crisis, and the subsequent double dip recession triggered a collapse in credit quality as excessive leverage and weak profitability among Italian corporates and SMEs caused bank loans to sour.

A special feature from our sponsor SYZ Asset Management – ‘Contrarian investing in the Italian banking crisis’

The situation in Italy was exacerbated by the unique structure of its system. More than half of the sector consists of mutual or cooperative banks that have strong ties to the local communities in which they operate. This strong connection with clients, coupled with poor underwriting, led to a sharp ramp up in lending prior to the financial crisis. The subsequent losses in these portfolios were compounded by excessive red-tape and a weak and inefficient judicial system that made it difficult to collect loans or seize the collateral underpinning those portfolios.




Italian NPL market

Source : PWC, “The Italian unlikely to pay market” Data as at 31.05.2017

Source : PWC, “The Italian unlikely to pay market” Data as at 31.05.2017


The NPL crisis peaked last year, as fears began to mount that the rising losses could trigger a spate of bank failures including Monte Dei Paschi (MPS) and maybe even the banking giant, Unicredit. With confidence in the sector crumbling, liquidity pressures spiked as depositors fled the weakest banks for fear they could also lose money if their bank failed. As a number of banks edged towards failure, share prices plummeted to deeply distressed levels.


Finding the right contrarian opportunity

We sensed there was a contrarian investment opportunity amidst this crisis, but struggled to put a floor on the downside of the banks. Investors were focused mainly on MPS and Unicredit – both had massive NPL portfolios and needed to raise capital. Both teams were under enormous pressure to convince investors that they could turn around the fortunes of their banks. In the end MPS shareholders were wiped out while Unicredit shares recovered. While MPS potentially had more upside at the time (given its very distressed valuation), Unicredit ultimately had the more credible business plan with more levers to pull and assets to sell.

We steered clear of investing directly in the banks, but we did find two very interesting opportunities to play the recovery without taking on the same risks: Eurocastle and Anima.


Eurocastle: tapping the EUR300bn NPL opportunity

In our view, the Italian NPL crisis was an ideal hunting ground for debt purchasers and loan servicers. The market was full of distressed sellers of NPLs and the +EUR300bn mountain of NPLs would have to be serviced and cleared one way or another.


Eurocastle NAV

Source: Eurocastle Data as at 31.08.2017


Eurocastle share price vs discount to NAV

Source: Eurocastle, Bloomberg Data as at 31.08.2017


We saw two clear opportunities in this area for Eurocastle. Firstly, its investment in doBank was materially undervalued in our opinion. Around 40% of Eurocastle’s NAV consisted of its investment in doBank. doBank is the leading NPL servicer in the market with cEUR80bn of NPLs being managed on behalf of some key clients including Unicredit, Intesa and Fortress. The over EUR300bn stock of NPLs in the market still needs to be addressed, and we believe the independent servicers will play a key part. In July 2017, doBank was IPO’d valuing Eurocastle’s stake at EUR350m and the doBank shares have since appreciated another 20%. We continue to see the long-term potential in doBank, and therefore participated directly in the IPO.

The second opportunity for Eurocastle is investing directly in Italian NPLs and distressed real estate. Eurocastle’s manager, Fortress, has been successfully investing in the Italian NPL market for several years. This has enabled it to build a strong platform for pricing, acquiring and managing NPLs including the plan, named FINO, to reorganise Unicredit’s NPLs. By investing in Eurocastle, we obtained exposure to a recovery in the Italian banking system but without the risks associated with investing directly in a bank. 


Anima: a play on MPS but without the risk

Anima is the leading independent asset manager in Italy. Its distribution is primarily through its network of partner banks, including MPS and Banco Popolare Milano (BPM). Anima’s shares had been sold off on fears that the AuM sourced through the MPS and BPM networks were at risk. After careful analysis, we concluded that the share price was broadly pricing in the very worst-case scenario. We struggled to see this scenario panning out, even in the event MPS failed and needed restructuring. As we were able to put a floor on the downside, we felt more comfortable investing in Anima with the upside gearing coming from a stabilisation in the situations of MPS and BPM.

In the space of nine months, sentiment towards Anima has moved from fearing a worst-case scenario of losing its major distributors to trying to price in the upside opportunities from Anima fully penetrating the giant distribution networks of Poste Italiane, BAMI and a restructured MPS. Following the acquisition of Aletti, Anima will now have unparalleled distribution in Italy, with access to more than 4500 branches focused in some of richest parts of the country.


Anima/Aletti coverage maps

Source: ANIMA, «ANIMA and Banco BPM – Acquisition of Aletti Gestielle SGR» presentation Data as at 31.08.2017






“This advertisement has been approved for issue in the UK by SYZ Asset Management ( Europe ) Limited (authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority with reference number 666766 to provide investment services to Professional Investors).  This advertisement is intended to the Professional Investors only. An investment involves risks. The information or data contained in this advertisement does not in any way constitute an offer or a recommendation to invest nor does it in any manner constitute the provision of investment advice in relation to same”.


Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!