We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".



Twitter board

Follow us
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 4 New Followers. See yours with https://t.co/mCw3VcMQGw https://t.co/odYllgQghg2 days ago
  • Friday View: Border to Coast launches UK equity tender - Rentokil Trustee faces fine - Gleeson directors banned - P… https://t.co/wx2SJ0bGfG4 days ago
  • Shareholder engagement: It’s good to talk For responsible investors talk isn’t cheap. Not only does research sugges… https://t.co/imwrezJuKJ4 days ago
  • Friday View: PA's DB scheme signs buy-out deal - PIC invests in Midlands housing association - Newton Video on Emer… https://t.co/GbWDdyENlN11 days ago
  • RT @minerva_ESG: Hey, all #ESG and#corpgov tweeps, lend a hand to @portfolio_inst important opportunity to support investors' understanding…12 days ago
  • We want to know your appetite and understanding for ESG! Please click the link to take our 5 minute survey to tell… https://t.co/SsVgQzEKIc12 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Great event, thanks for hosting @portfolio_inst. Inspired location too! https://t.co/we7Ou46ns312 days ago
  • Full house at our Portfolio Prepared event, Oliver Hamilton Illiquids specialist @AonRetirementUK discusses conside… https://t.co/F0qPFPjUSP13 days ago
  • West Midlland Pension Fund’s Jill Davys: “I am reluctant to overpay for assets” Assistant director of investments a… https://t.co/YHtEIU5BSN15 days ago
  • Friday View: DWP plans ÂŁ1m fine for "reckless" sponsors - Veolia appoints actuary - TPR fines Smart Pensions - UK s… https://t.co/9kUsw6mric18 days ago
  • RT @NewtonIM: Take 5 minutes to complete the @portfolio_inst ESG survey, which is part of its 'Raising Standards in ESG' initiative, and sh…18 days ago
  • This months cover story: Carillion: Lessons for trustees ''The collapse of the construction giant raises questions… https://t.co/L48HDqT0lB19 days ago
  • RT @PensionsSion: Portfolio Prepared? Join us and @portfolio_inst on 4th July 2018 to hear presentations from leading professional #trustee…19 days ago
  • Breaking: DWP proposes ÂŁ1m fine for "reckless" DB sponsors https://t.co/7rsDaGgS5v #DWP #DBWhitepaper #TPR https://t.co/YQqy9Qr7tN21 days ago
  • Our latest Roundtable: Factor Investing ''Pursuing value, momentum, quality or low volatility strategies in bond an… https://t.co/qugefevAN421 days ago
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 2 Mentions, 3.3K Mention Reach, 5 Likes, 6 Retweets, 7.76K Retweet Reach. See yours with… https://t.co/IZfviidt4H23 days ago
  • Friday View: Trustees feel the heat over climate change - bankers' pensions back in black - TPR suspends trustee -… https://t.co/kUKa8QUF9w25 days ago
  • Increased regulatory oversight will be risk-based, TPR keyperson will meet schemes deemed riskier several times a y… https://t.co/wUiKPGESaU27 days ago
  • Lesley Titcomb, TPR chief executive says change is on its way, the regulator will increase oversight between valuat… https://t.co/Wu8Pv6TfqS27 days ago
  • Join us and @AonRetirementUK on the 4th of July at the luxurious Victorian Bath House featuring educational presen… https://t.co/r1abr8Qls028 days ago


Defined benefit schemes’ Catch-22

Defined benefit schemes’ Catch-22

Mark Dunne
Friday 21st July 2017

The head of EMEA pensions at JP Morgan Asset Management has described schemes selling assets to pay member benefits while working to repair funding levels as like “trying to fill a bath with the plug out”.

Sorca Kelly-Scholte told portfolio institutional that each cash outflow pulls the funding level down while increasing the investment return needed to pay its obligations.

She said that many defined benefit (DB) schemes are stuck in a Catch-22 situation where under-funded schemes are tipping into negative cashflow but have to generate the returns needed to pay their members in a low yield market.

No matter how a fund is performing, how healthy its funding or returns are, retired members still need paying.

But 55% of retirement funds are not generating enough cash to do this, Mercer reported in June, up from 42% a year earlier. The situation is expected to deteriorate, with 85% of those currently cashflow positive expecting to generate insufficient cash for their needs by 2027.

Research from Spence Johnson shows that more than 80% of pension funds are selling assets to pay their members, which Kelly-Scholte labels as “not sustainable as a long-term strategy”.

Relying on income-generating assets to pay benefits works if the fund is “marginally” cashflow negative. It could be a bigger problem the deeper the fund is in the red. “When 3%, 4%, 5% of a scheme’s assets each year have to go out to service cashflow that is no longer an income strategy,” Kelly-Scholte said.

So funds cannot rely on a defensive strategy focused on gilts to repair their funding levels and pay their obligations in a low yield environment. In response some investment bosses are revising their strategies to include long-term real assets, such as property and infrastructure, that can provide a base level of cashflow.

Pension funds are exploring this cashflow driven investment space, Kelly-Scholte said, principally through ground leases and social housing bonds, although she points to concerns over capacity constraints.

For more on cashflow driven investment, read the June/July edition of portfolio institutional magazine.


Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!

Friday View

Friday View

Shareholder engagement: