We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".


Twitter board

Follow us
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 1 Retweet, 2.63K Retweet Reach, 3 New Followers. See yours with https://t.co/mCw3VcMQGw https://t.co/78tC0GzGXxyesterday
  • Our cover story: CDC: A step into the unknown. Is CDC an unnecessary policy change when effort would be better spen… https://t.co/QGHfTkiPP24 days ago
  • Newton – Trend Setting: The Year Ahead in ESG ''We have seen notable client interest for sustainable products over… https://t.co/OoXVLJ1BMp4 days ago
  • Our Latest ESG feature: EM governance: Breaking through. ''Those calling for better governance in emerging markets… https://t.co/qk0vJpfpJL7 days ago
  • The February Issue is available online now! Our Cover Story - CDC: A Step in the wrong direction. Read more here:… https://t.co/8xwHL9Nd2z7 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: What do we expect to see in the #ESG market over the next 12 months? Read the results of the @portfolio_inst panel of…7 days ago
  • RT @PensionsSion: What are the pros and cons of building a global #equity portfolio? Find out by reading the @portfolio_inst Global Equitie…13 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Outcomes delivered by employer pension schemes now depend more than ever on levels of engagement. Companies must creat…14 days ago
  • Our latest Roundtable: Cash-Flow Driven Investing is now live! Read more here: https://t.co/zBy7Gbiud9 https://t.co/KJTIgVssmG14 days ago
  • RT @BNPPAM_COM: 2017 was one of the most active hurricane seasons on record, causing up to USD 475 billion worth of damage. What are the in…26 days ago
  • RT @PensionsTony: At the Aon London #pensions conference. About to start my workshop on how well #DC schemes are meeting the needs of #memb…26 days ago
  • Andrew Wauchope talks to Mark Dunne about charities and their pension schemes, the secret of being a good trustee a… https://t.co/xcdcxs61QL26 days ago
  • Enter the Dragon : China’s inclusion in the @MSCI_Inc Emerging Market index has caused little excitement, but, as L… https://t.co/oy0EdSI6A828 days ago
  • The @InvescoUKinsti whitepaper: Responsible investing and active ownership. Invesco’s Bonnie Saynay and Henning St… https://t.co/E3Gdh9eDSM33 days ago
  • Charlotte Moore looks at the reaction of financial markets to Brexit has already changed the shape of the relations… https://t.co/6KH9jnWTtq33 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Want to know more about the benefits of factor-based investing for your DB pension scheme? Aon’s next Investment Break…34 days ago
  • Learn more about why everyone is talking ESG on our new ESG HUB, where we will be publishing our latest features pl… https://t.co/Dg9FiwCPCn35 days ago
  • 2018: The year of the human?. Cyber crime, greater disclosure, fixed income, people and, of course, climate change.… https://t.co/HMkzWcrFNy35 days ago
  • ''Building a global portfolio of equities could also provide much needed diversification'', discover why in our Glo… https://t.co/y90GhLlmCD35 days ago
  • What is your stance on executive pay? is bigger really better? Read more in our new ESG feature:… https://t.co/cUXMiCDuE560 days ago


Plain sailing in choppy waters: Bob Holmes

Plain sailing in choppy waters: Bob Holmes

Interview by Sebastian Cheek
Tuesday 21st February 2017

The £200m Dover Harbour Board Pension and Life Assurance Scheme closed its DB plan to future accrual in May last year. Trustee chairman Bob Holmes tells Sebastian Cheek how having strong employer-backing has helped the scheme deal with this closure.

Plain sailing in choppy waters: Bob Holmes

"All the employer's available cashflow over the next 10 to 15 years needs to be directed towards servicing [the harbour regeneration] which means it won't have much, if any, spare cash to bail out the pension scheme."

Bob Holmes

Why was it necessary to close the defined benefit scheme to future accrual last year?

The Dover Harbour board (the board) has had a defined benefit (DB) pension scheme for several years, but, like most other employers who have set up such schemes, it reached the stage when it became unaffordable. With interest rates being as low as they are, the ongoing funding rate became too high.

It first closed two new entrants on 1 January 2014 and, as pension trustees, we said, “Okay, well that had to happen” and  conceded it would probably only be a  matter of time before the board closed the scheme to future accrual as well. That happened on 31 May 2016.

What has replaced the DB scheme?

After the DB scheme first closed to new  members, the company put in place a good contract [DC] arrangement for new  employees, but that scheme was enhanced when the DB scheme was closed to existing employees last year. The replacement scheme is very generous. There are four levels of contribution that new members can put in, varying between 4% and 10% of their salary.

The company will not only match that, but will also put in 1.5 times whatever they put in up to that limit. So if somebody puts in 10% of their salary, the board will put 15% in for them, which, as an employer’s contribution, I think is probably one of the most generous DC arrangements around. Now, the minimum total contribution of 10% won’t buy the sort of benefits that were available under the old scheme, but if people are prepared to make a bit of a sacrifice by contributing more then they’re getting closer.

So the employer covenant remains strong, despite competition from the likes of Eurotunnel?

Even with Brexit, the ferry market is still going to be there and will continue to grow. People are still going to be travelling to the continent, freight and trade is still going to be coming in and out of the country.  Dover’s main competition is Eurotunnel, but the capacity of the tunnel is rather more finite than the capacity of the port.

Slightly more passengers use Eurotunnel than use the ferries, but slightly more freight uses the ferries than uses the tunnel. From our perspective as trustees, we’re in the good position of having a very solid sponsoring employer and therefore, the strength of the employer covenant should not be an issue. Nonetheless, we need to be prudent and we always have been prudent as trustees.

How has the DB closure affected the role of the trustees?

Over the course of the last three years or so, our focus has gone from being trustees of a scheme which is fully open, to one which is now fully closed. That’s certainly had a bit of an impact. But probably the bigger  impact, rather than the closure of the scheme, has been the fact that the board is about to engage in a significant capital  expenditure programme, called the Dover Western Docks Revival (DWDR).

What does the DWDR entail?

The board is inherently profitable and generates cash in a normal year which is good news from our perspective. The board is a trust port which means it does not have shareholders, which from a trustee perspective is also good news because it means there aren’t any dividends that have to be  paid out of cashflows. However, the profits do have to be reinvested in the port and  every so often you have some very significant capital expenditure that comes along; you need to build a new quay or do a lot of work on link-spans or things like that. The DWDR plan is to redevelop and regenerate the western side of the port to provide  additional capacity that will allow the port to handle the growth in traffic expected over the coming years. The scale of the project is five times its annual turnover which is about £60m and this is a £300m capital investment. That has to be funded.

Page: 1 2 3

Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!