We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".



Twitter board

Follow us
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 2 Mentions, 3.3K Mention Reach, 5 Likes, 6 Retweets, 7.76K Retweet Reach. See yours with… https://t.co/IZfviidt4H16 hours ago
  • Friday View: Trustees feel the heat over climate change - bankers' pensions back in black - TPR suspends trustee -… https://t.co/kUKa8QUF9w3 days ago
  • Increased regulatory oversight will be risk-based, TPR keyperson will meet schemes deemed riskier several times a y… https://t.co/wUiKPGESaU5 days ago
  • Lesley Titcomb, TPR chief executive says change is on its way, the regulator will increase oversight between valuat… https://t.co/Wu8Pv6TfqS5 days ago
  • Join us and @AonRetirementUK on the 4th of July at the luxurious Victorian Bath House featuring educational presen… https://t.co/r1abr8Qls06 days ago
  • DWP wants trustees to feel the heat over climate change https://t.co/bs25DvyWGF #ESG #climatechange https://t.co/dZEXB0g8a46 days ago
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 3 New Followers. See yours with https://t.co/mCw3VcMQGw https://t.co/3kEHNr3xyz7 days ago
  • Friday View: Heathrow's ÂŁ325 million buy-in - Auto enrolment for the gig economy - Brunel opts for ACS structure -… https://t.co/vsnML1Vzb510 days ago
  • Pimlico Plumbers- Could gig economy workers be auto enrolled? https://t.co/qgrlWxMUW8 #gigeconomy #autoenrolment… https://t.co/wnDH18iPxG10 days ago
  • RT @eVestment: Workers in the #UK are open to increasing their retirement savings and tend to place greater emphasis on workplace #pensions…11 days ago
  • The June issue of portfolio institutional is now out: Featuring our take on #carillion and lessons for trustees as… https://t.co/yC2PNgoaPr12 days ago
  • RT @PensionsSion: Aon's very own John Belgrove shares his views in this piece. Worth reading... https://t.co/VYEJWjAU3z12 days ago
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 2 Mentions, 3.29K Mention Reach, 2 Retweets, 3.27K Retweet Reach. See yours with… https://t.co/MeoES7Ch3L14 days ago
  • Friday View: South Yorkshire hedges pension risk- Recruitment execs face prison over pension scam - Johnston Press… https://t.co/9fV8Z48WtF17 days ago
  • RT @cfjescott: A recent piece of mine on the @CMAgovUK investigation into investment consultants in @portfolio_inst #investment https://t.c…19 days ago
  • Our ESG Roundtable: Better Long-term outcomes? Available to download now https://t.co/o7T8kWSwWY https://t.co/oHs4VlRK9E21 days ago
  • Active vs Passive : In 2016 investors withdrew around $285bn from active funds and pumped almost $429bn into passiv… https://t.co/tjpxhTxW5Z21 days ago
  • RT @WhtstheDiehlio: .@AitkenRL spoke with @graniteshares CEO Will Rhind about the ongoing active vs. passive debate. Check out their though…21 days ago
  • Green is the new black. A record sum is expected to be raised under the green bond banner this year, but is it doom… https://t.co/JYP8k0ZfZk23 days ago
  • Our Cover Story! Property: Solid Returns - Low gilt yields are forcing schemes to pile into bricks and mortar. Mark… https://t.co/9nyjFp0Z4R23 days ago


Geopolitical risk:  Predicting the unpredictable

Geopolitical risk: Predicting the unpredictable

Charlotte Moore
Tuesday 17th October 2017

With many asset managers having a poor track record of correctly predicting political outcomes, Charlotte Moore asks if they should just give up and stick to picking stocks.

"For a fund manager to be successful, they need to have a particular view of the world and the conviction to stick to this opinion."

Daniel Banks, P-Solve

For a group of individuals whose success relies on their ability to assess risk and make predictions about the future; most fund managers are surprisingly bad at analysing and predicting political events. Evidence of this shortfall is somewhat nebulous – it cannot be assessed as objectively as the performance of a particular fund. But there are various clues. The financial markets’ conviction that Remain would win despite the tightness of the polls is one such hint.

Not only do asset managers struggle to predict the outcomes of referendums and elections but they find it difficult to correctly interpret political events. For example, many managers’ were convinced that a Trump presidency would be productive rather than chaotic, even though he has no political acumen.

While much of the evidence is anecdotal, there is also some concrete evidence. P-Solve recently looked at emerging market equity managers’ ability to select stock, sectors and countries.

P-Solve director Daniel Banks says: “We found that while managers were pretty good at selecting both stocks and sectors, their ability to predict which country would outperform was usually very poor. This is of particular importance in emerging markets, as country selection drives almost all returns.

Banks says: “The irony is that most were focusing on bottom-up stock selection yet the most important decision – the country selection – was happening by accident rather than design.”

It’s easy to explain why emerging market fund managers focus solely on individual companies and sectors: if predicting geopolitical outcomes is hard and it’s very easy to get it wrong, then the simpler option is to not bother.

Tapan Datta, head of asset allocation at Aon Hewitt, says: “The instinct to not even try to get a handle on, for example, the risks associated with Brexit are understandable.” When the outlook is that uncertain, it’s basic human behaviour to choose not to think about it and instead to pretend it’s not a factor.

But this the wrong approach to the problem. Datta says: “When issues are truly uncertain and it’s impossible to predict the probability of it occurring with any great accuracy, they should command more, not less, of a manager’s attention.”

Page: 1 2 3

Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!

Friday View

Friday View

How investor action helps cut CO2 emissions