We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".



Twitter board

Follow us
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 4 New Followers. See yours with https://t.co/mCw3VcMQGw https://t.co/odYllgQghg2 days ago
  • Friday View: Border to Coast launches UK equity tender - Rentokil Trustee faces fine - Gleeson directors banned - P… https://t.co/wx2SJ0bGfG4 days ago
  • Shareholder engagement: It’s good to talk For responsible investors talk isn’t cheap. Not only does research sugges… https://t.co/imwrezJuKJ4 days ago
  • Friday View: PA's DB scheme signs buy-out deal - PIC invests in Midlands housing association - Newton Video on Emer… https://t.co/GbWDdyENlN11 days ago
  • RT @minerva_ESG: Hey, all #ESG and#corpgov tweeps, lend a hand to @portfolio_inst important opportunity to support investors' understanding…12 days ago
  • We want to know your appetite and understanding for ESG! Please click the link to take our 5 minute survey to tell… https://t.co/SsVgQzEKIc12 days ago
  • RT @AonRetirementUK: Great event, thanks for hosting @portfolio_inst. Inspired location too! https://t.co/we7Ou46ns312 days ago
  • Full house at our Portfolio Prepared event, Oliver Hamilton Illiquids specialist @AonRetirementUK discusses conside… https://t.co/F0qPFPjUSP13 days ago
  • West Midlland Pension Fund’s Jill Davys: “I am reluctant to overpay for assets” Assistant director of investments a… https://t.co/YHtEIU5BSN15 days ago
  • Friday View: DWP plans £1m fine for "reckless" sponsors - Veolia appoints actuary - TPR fines Smart Pensions - UK s… https://t.co/9kUsw6mric18 days ago
  • RT @NewtonIM: Take 5 minutes to complete the @portfolio_inst ESG survey, which is part of its 'Raising Standards in ESG' initiative, and sh…18 days ago
  • This months cover story: Carillion: Lessons for trustees ''The collapse of the construction giant raises questions… https://t.co/L48HDqT0lB19 days ago
  • RT @PensionsSion: Portfolio Prepared? Join us and @portfolio_inst on 4th July 2018 to hear presentations from leading professional #trustee…19 days ago
  • Breaking: DWP proposes £1m fine for "reckless" DB sponsors https://t.co/7rsDaGgS5v #DWP #DBWhitepaper #TPR https://t.co/YQqy9Qr7tN21 days ago
  • Our latest Roundtable: Factor Investing ''Pursuing value, momentum, quality or low volatility strategies in bond an… https://t.co/qugefevAN421 days ago
  • My week on Twitter 🎉: 2 Mentions, 3.3K Mention Reach, 5 Likes, 6 Retweets, 7.76K Retweet Reach. See yours with… https://t.co/IZfviidt4H23 days ago
  • Friday View: Trustees feel the heat over climate change - bankers' pensions back in black - TPR suspends trustee -… https://t.co/kUKa8QUF9w25 days ago
  • Increased regulatory oversight will be risk-based, TPR keyperson will meet schemes deemed riskier several times a y… https://t.co/wUiKPGESaU27 days ago
  • Lesley Titcomb, TPR chief executive says change is on its way, the regulator will increase oversight between valuat… https://t.co/Wu8Pv6TfqS27 days ago
  • Join us and @AonRetirementUK on the 4th of July at the luxurious Victorian Bath House featuring educational presen… https://t.co/r1abr8Qls028 days ago


An unhappy comparison?

An unhappy comparison?

Tuesday 18th November 2014

Humans have an irresistible urge to compare their performance against their peers. As English dramatist and poet laureate, Thomas Shadwell, famously said: “No man is happy but by comparison.” Shadwell died in 1692, nearly 100 years before the birth of stock exchanges in 1773.

And still the urge lives on. In investment terms, comparison often means looking at the gap between how an investment has performed and a commonly accepted measure of that particular universe, or benchmark.

And, with passive investment on the rise since the financial crisis, the dominance of broad market benchmarks in investors’ psyche is on the increase. Today, the S&P 500 has become one of the most commonly used benchmarks by which to compare equity market performance. It is widely considered to be one of the best representations of the US stock market, and a bellwether for the US economy. In 2013, S&P Dow Jones Indices estimated more than $7trn of assets globally were explicitly benchmarked to the S&P 500 through index- tracking mutual funds, institutional funds, separately managed accounts, indexed insurance products and ETFs.

This doesn’t include the unofficial benchmarking many investors do by comparing the performance of a range of assets against this widely held barometer or investment performance. It is not uncommon, for example, to see comparisons of hedge funds’ performance reported against the S&P 500 even though those hedge funds are generally not designed to produce performance in line with this benchmark.


At the holistic portfolio level, investors are increasingly adopting an outcome-oriented approach to investment, particularly as many pension funds, for example, close or move to liability-matching strategies. As such, more and more are taking a more self-centric approach to performance, focusing instead on bespoke benchmarks that capture their individual liability stream.

As Andrew Kirton, EuroPac investments head at Mercer, says: “Almost universally in today’s market, institutional investors will have their own unique investment strategy. For defined benefit pension plans, in addition, the investment strategy will evolve dynamically given the objective for many is to de-risk the portfolio over time.

“The advent of scheme-specific investment strategies is not a new development, but arguably dates from the turn of the current century when mark-to-market valuation techniques were introduced by the actuaries in response to changing accounting standards. At the total portfolio level benchmarks are often expressed as a ‘journey’, over a specified time period to a desired level of solvency and set of risk parameters.”

However, outcome-oriented or self-centric measurement of performance often disappears at the asset level, where broad market benchmarks are still commonly used as reference points. As Aon Hewitt senior partner John Belgrove puts it: “To know if a manager is doing a good job, you need a benchmark that is representative of their opportunity set to judge them against. Undeniably cap-weighted benchmarks are the dominant form of investment measurement in the market. They are a fair and full representation of the opportunity set of a market and still the purest form of beta.”

In this context, benchmarks and indices serve a number of purposes to investors. As well as being representative of the performance across a given universe of securities (i.e. the money-weighted current opinion of value), they do not require rebalancing or transaction costs to maintain.

“They are one of the very best capital market innovations of the last 40 years,” according to Bob Maynard, chief investment officer of the $15bn Public Employee Retirement System of Idaho (PERSI). “Kudos to Bill Fouse and Wells Fargo for making it happen. They are also the cheapest alternative to an active management or other investment approach, and thus are a measure of a basic value-add.”

Page: 1 2 3

Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!

Friday View

Friday View

Shareholder engagement: