We use cookies to support features like login and allow trusted media partners to analyse aggregated site usage.
To dismiss this message and allow cookies to be used, please click "Continue".



Twitter board

Follow us
  • RT @PensionsSion: Portfolio Prepared? Join us and @portfolio_inst on 4th July 2018 to hear presentations on latest investment trends, helpi…yesterday
  • RT @csgmoore: My latest feature for @portfolio_inst where I use the USS crisis to explain everything you wanted to know about valuing defin…yesterday
  • RT @JohnRalfe1: @csgmoore @portfolio_inst Very good piece #USSyesterday
  • RT @eVestment: How is interest in #realestate impacting the #UK pension business? @portfolio_inst has a look https://t.co/1w82Kz4o6Vyesterday
  • Karen Shackleton @MJHudsonCorp #SRI implementation as part of risk management is mainstream now @portfolio_inst #SRI Roundtableyesterday
  • John Olsen: "A key strength of the British asset management industry is now asset managers get together and work on… https://t.co/ADtXBGga0qyesterday
  • Discussing investment challenges at the @portfolio_inst #SRI Roundtable with @esmeefairbairn @AonHewitt… https://t.co/r1iYOrYeloyesterday
  • Lively debates at the @portfolio_inst #SRI Roundtable https://t.co/9j0ajME8Ztyesterday
  • John Olsen, fund manager: "Industry wide frameworks on #SRI can kill a lot of constructive dialogue" @MandGcareeers @mandgprofyesterday
  • Tim Manuel @AonHewitt: Challenge with passive #SRI investing - your outcomes could be completely different dependin… https://t.co/U1OjPYqd2syesterday
  • Wim van Hyfte: Short term benchmarking is a huge challenge to #SRI investing which should be more long-term oriented @candriamyesterday
  • Wim van Hyfte, global head of responsible investments and research @candriam : I'm not sure we need a universal def… https://t.co/qvYRbFglf3yesterday
  • Tim Manuel, UK head of responsible investment @AonHewitt: "The best way to progress the discussion on ESG is to foc… https://t.co/hCSwTi55Qqyesterday
  • James Brooke Turner, investment director, @NuffieldFound :"It is no longer acceptable to make money at any price"… https://t.co/vUKTy2ENcYyesterday
  • Beatrice Hollond, trustee at @esmeefairbairn Foundation says overall, pension funds should be responsible investor… https://t.co/4UZcRdjxF5yesterday
  • Our Responsible Investment round table is kicking off, featuring @esmeefairbairn @AonHewitt @MandGCareers… https://t.co/81pUdO6DBYyesterday
  • Beatrice Hollond: "When we started the #ESG focus was very much on smaller funds, we now implement it as part of ou… https://t.co/YyNm9OUoFsyesterday
  • Karen Shackleton @MJHudsonCorp "I can easily see pension funds applying ESG in all equity and bonds investments, th… https://t.co/Fiv4xmbrPKyesterday
  • Tim Manuel @AonHewitt "the benefit of divestment is that is very easy to implement, #ESG engagement requires a much more nuanced approach"yesterday
  • Beatrice Hollond @esmeefairbairn #ESG Engagement with boards can have a deeper impact over time "yesterday


Active vs passive

Active vs passive

Roger Aitken
Tuesday 15th May 2018

Roger Aitken takes a closer look at one of the biggest ongoing debates in the investment world to see what lies ahead.

The direction of travel in the active versus passive investing debate has largely remained static for several years. In a nutshell, increasing amounts of money have been flowing out of actively managed investment funds and into passively managed ones. Is this a short-term trend or could it be part of a longer-term change?

In 2016 investors withdrew around $285bn from active funds and pumped almost $429bn into passive strategies. The picture was pretty similar last year, according to investment researcher Morningstar. Its figures show that while the active fund industry is much larger than the passive world – at $23.9trn versus $6.7trn – the gap is closing.

Offering a cheaper way to invest is certainly catching investors’ attention with passive funds growing more than four times faster than their active counterpartsin 2016. Moreover, Deutsche Bank estimates that passive funds will have as much cash allocated to them as active ones within a few years.


In terms of their respective approaches to investing, active investors follow and research companies closely and buy and sell stocks based on their future view. Passive investors, by contrast, typical mirror an index and purchase a basket of stocks and buy more or less regularly – irrespective of how the market is performing. It requires a long-term investing mindset compared to an active approach.

Passive fund managers pursuing this approach are content to perform at the market average – be it Standard & Poor’s 500 index of large US-listed companies, the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the FTSE 100 or DAX. But investors can also choose a mix and match approach. For example, they can be active traders of passive funds (i.e. betting on the direction of the market as opposed to buying and holding as a ‘true’ passive investor would). On the converse, passive investors can decide to hold actively managed funds in their portfolio on the basis that a robust money manager can outperformthe market.

Page: 1 2 3 4 5

Leave your comment

View our comments policy

Please login or register with us to leave a comment. It's completely free!

Friday View

Friday View

How investor action helps cut CO2 emissions