TAKING STOCK – Share Buybacks and Shareholder Value
1. Share buybacks have become the favored means for distributing cash to investors among large-cap U.S. companies, exceeding cash dividends every year since 1997 at
388 of the 610 companies (63.6%) we studied.
2. A majority of the companies we observed bought back shares when prices were high rather than low, as buybacks have replaced dividends as the dominant way of
returning cash to investors at many companies.
3. Contrary to concerns expressed by many observers, we found no compelling evidence of a negative impact from share buybacks on long-term value creation for
investors overall. In each of the areas we examined, beginning with MSCI ESG Ratings but also including CAPEX, R&D, new debt issues, and, most importantly,
value creation, the companies that were most actively distributing cash to their investors were also the strongest companies.
4. Companies where index investors were the largest shareholders included a much wider range of buyback impacts, good and bad, than companies where the largest
shareholders were buy-and-hold investors: total returns for the buy-and-hold investor companies were 18% higher, on average, than for the index investor
companies from 2007 to 2016.
To download the whitepaper in full please click the link below: